Archived Legal Articles from 2018
Allen v Cycle Route Ltd t/a Override Skate Park
In 2015 the claimant attended a skate park owned by the defendant accompanied by a guardian. The 11-year-old claimant was scooting along the street section of the park, consisting of a drop down ramp to a flat bank which included a grind rail, when he…
Construction Company and Director Prosecuted for Dangerous Building Site
A construction company was fined and its managing director ordered to carry out 150 community service after HSE Inspectors found dangerous conditions at its building site.
According to the HSE, inspectors had visited the…
Clive Bellman (A protected party by his litigation friend, Susan Thomas) v Northampton Recruitment Ltd (2018) EWCA Civ 2214
The Court of Appeal has held a company vicariously liable for an assault committed by its managing director on an employee after a Christmas party.
In 2010 the…
Peter John Sebastian Murray v Martin Devenish (on his own behalf & as representative of all other members of the unincorporated association known as The Sons of the Sacred Heart of Jesus) (2018) EWHC 1895 (QB) QBD (Nicol J) 24/07/2018
The claimant alleged that he had been sexually abused…
Witley Parish Council has lost its appeal against a decision that it was negligent after a tree fell and injured Mr Cavanagh whilst he was driving a bus.
In 2012 after a stormy night, a large lime tree situated on the Council's land next to a bus stop fell across the road at the same moment as…
The Homes (Fitness for Human Habitation) Bill 2017-19 is currently making its way through Parliament. The Bill seeks to amend the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 to ensure rented accommodation is provided and maintained in a state of fitness for human habitation, and to amend the Building Act 1984 to…
Back to top
According to the HSE the construction industry is one of the most hazardous industries in the country with around one third of all workplace fatalities occurring in construction. In the last 10 years more than 750 people (workers and members of the public) have died from injuries arising out of…
Hartley v Preston CC
A claimant whose case for personal injury included multiple descriptions of the accident circumstances was found to be fundamentally dishonest at the conclusion of his trial.
The claimant alleged that on Saturday 28th November 2015 at approximately 4.30pm he…
Lovell v Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council
A claimant discontinued his claim at trial after proceeding on the erroneous basis that a highway is the same as a highway maintainable at the public expense.
The claimant alleged that he was walking along an alleyway when he tripped, fell and…
Hussain v Oldham Metropolitan Borough Council
July 2018 - Manchester CC
The claimant in this matter was found to be 'fundamentally dishonest' following the trial of his claim for personal injury. The judge delivered a no holds barred judgment declaring the claimant to…
Increasing trend of significant fines based on turnover irrespective of the status of the organisation
Two Construction Companies Fined £1.4 million After Worker Injured
Two construction companies have been fined after a worker's foot was trapped in a large rotating screw…
Claims for damages as a consequence of abuse show no signs of abating and remain a significant expense to Local Authorities. Claims for damages are often based upon an argument by the victim that the abuse they suffered has directly contributed to difficulties in their lives, such as, loss of earning…
Under new court guidelines to be introduced on 1st November 2018, managers charged with gross negligence manslaughter will face longer prison terms up to 18 years.
It is the first time that the Sentencing Council have drawn up guidelines for these serious and difficult cases. Such cases are often…
There has been a recent spate of decisions concerning the issue of vicarious liability. Over the years, the concept of vicarious liability (which refers to a situation where an employer can be held strictly liable for the acts or omissions of its employees) has evolved and extended its reach for reasons…
Back to top
Mercel Hislop v Laura Perde : Kundan Kaur v Committee (For The Time Being) Of Ramgarhia Board Leicester (2018) EWCA Civ 1726
The Court of Appeal determined that a claimant was not entitled to standard or indemnity costs where a defendant accepted a Part 36 offer out of time but before trial…
Ratcliffe v Oldham Metropolitan Borough Council
District Judge Swindley - Manchester CC
The local authority has successfully defended a claim following a fall on a defective kerb.
The claimant was out walking one evening; she fell when she put her right foot forward onto the kerb which…
James Lewis -v- Burry Port AFC
The claimant was playing in a junior football match for the defendant. During the course of the game the claimant made a sliding tackle and suffered a laceration to his leg. It transpired that there was glass embedded in the surface of the pitch.
Tesco Feels the Brunt of the Sentencing Guidelines
Tesco has been fined £160,000 after an employee was seriously injured in an incident involving a roll cage.
In September 2015, the employee was working alone to unload roll cages containing stock from a delivery vehicle. The worker…
The Claims Regulator (CMR) has published its annual report. In the report, the CMR confirms that within the past year they have successfully managed to strike down misconduct in the holiday sickness claims market. However, the consequence of the crack down on holiday sickness claims appears to be an…
Pinkus v Direct Line  EWHC 1671 (QB)
In this RTA case, the judge made a finding of fundamental dishonesty when confronted by Facebook posts which revealed a very different view of the claimant's lifestyle and mental capacity to the one proffered by the claimant to the Court.
John Myles, a Partner in Forbes Solicitors' Insurance department has become the new President of Blackburn Incorporated Law Association (BiLA).
The Association exists to help local law practitioners and provides educational meetings and a range of support.
However in recent times…
Back to top
Allen v Oldham MBC - Manchester CC
The claimant alleged that he was out walking his friend's dog, when he tripped due to a pothole in the alleyway. He fell and sustained an injury. Breach of duty was admitted but the defendant remained unconvinced by the claim and put the claimant to strict…
Austin v Lancaster County Council
Local authorities often have to strike the balance between providing safe and exciting play areas for children as well as protecting the needs of local residents who live nearby. This claim arose after a child was injured after falling on a stone boulder installed…
DHL receives £2m fine after employee crushed by a reversing lorry
DHL has been fined £2m over the death of an employee who was crushed at a depot in Milton Keynes. The worked was trapped between a reversing lorry and a loading bay in February 2015.
DHL admitted breaching s 2(1…
Tuson v Debbie Murphy (2018)  EWCA Civ 1461
The Court of Appeal considered whether a claimant ought to receive a cost penalty even though the defendant made the Part 36 offer in full knowledge of the misleading and dishonest conduct of the claimant.
The claimant, Ms Tuson, fell from her…
Philip Clarke v John Kerwin (T/A Dirtbike Action) (2018)CC (Carlisle) (Judge Peter Hughes QC) 26/04/2018
A claim for personal injury was dismissed after the Court found that the true cause of an accident occurring at a motorcycle event was the dangerously high speed at which the claimant had…
Philip Clay v TUI UK LTD (2018)  EWCA Civ 1177 CA (Civ Div) (Kitchin LJ, Hamblen LJ, Moylan LJ) 23/05/2018
The Court of Appeal have for the first time in a number of years considered when the actions of a claimant might break the chain of causation.
Mr Clay had been on a package holiday…
Back to top
Fishburn v Rochdale BC - Manchester County Court
A Claimant has discontinued her claim for personal injury after a poor performance in the witness box.
The Claimant alleged that she sustained a personal accident whilst walking along a pavement. The Claimant contended that she tripped on a…
Miles v Wigan Council
This claim arises following an alleged accident in March 2014 when the Claimant stated that she tripped as a result of a rocking flagstone. The Claimant sustained a displaced fracture to her left elbow which required surgical fixation and presented a schedule of special…
After what feels like an age of the GDPR looming on the horizon, the new data protection regime has finally been implemented into law. There is no grace period so those who handle data must be ready to hit the ground running. But what impact will the GDPR have on claims and those who process data for…
Contractors face £526,500 penalty for failure to plan work at height
An employee fell through a fragile roof at a leisure centre and sustained six fractures to his back.
A HSE investigation found that two contractors involved had failed to plan and manage the work at height risk. The…
This week the Courts Service has admitted that since introducing increased court fees in July 2016, claimants have been overcharged for issuing stage 3 proceedings. The overcharged Court fees will have been passed on to defendants or their insurers when stage 3 costs were subsequently claimed.
The House of Commons Justice Committee have examined the Small Claims limit for personal injury and have rejected the proposals to increase the small claims limit for personal injury claims from £1,000 to £2,000 and to £5,000 for road traffic accidents.
The Justice Committee have…
Back to top
Gilpin v Blackburn with Darwen Borough Council
Preston County Court
On 21 st May 2016, the claimant alighted from a taxi, took a few paces and stumbled in a pothole falling onto her outstretched hand and suffered injury. The claimant brought a claim against the local authority under the…
Potts v Wigan Council
District Judge Mornington - Wigan County Court
The claimant alleged that he was running along the pavement outside his home in May 2013 when he tripped on a raised paving slab. The claimant fractured his ankle as a result of the fall.
At trial, the claimant…
DHL fined £2m over death of an employee
An employee died after he was trapped between a reversing lorry and a loading bay at the company's site in 2015.
DHL admitted breaching s. 2(1) and 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act and was ordered to pay costs of £100,000…
In the case of Sally Woodward & Mark Addison v Phoenix Healthcare Distribution Limited the Court granted an order for retrospective alternative service of a claim form under CPR 6.15(2). The master found that the defendant's solicitors had breached their duty to further the overriding…
Sumner v Michael Colborne & Denbighshire County Council & Welsh Ministers (2018) EWCA Civ 1006
The Court of Appeal found that the highway authority did not owe a duty of care to highway users to cut back vegetation on land adjacent to the highway which interfered with drivers'…
Edward Wright v Satellite Information Services Ltd (2018) EWHC 812 (QB)
A Judge had been entitled to conclude that, for the purposes of the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015 s.57 ("CJCA"), a claimant had not been fundamentally dishonest in relation to his personal injury claim…
We are pleased to announce that the Forbes Insurance Department has been shortlisted for the British Claims Awards in the strongly contested categories of Defendant Law Firm of the year and Counter Fraud award.
The British Claims Awards celebrate the successes of leading professionals in the claims…
Back to top
Bailey v Warrington Borough Council and United Utilities Water Limited
St Helens CC - District Judge Simister
The Claimant alleged that she was walking along the pavement when she tripped on a defect in the pavement where a United Utilities stop tap grid cover was located.
At trial, the…
Health & Safety Fine for Tree Climbing Fall
Center Parcs UK has received a £250,000 fine and ordered to pay costs of £14,000 after an eight-year-old child fell from a tree and broke her wrist.
The child was participating in an organised tree climbing class. Prior to the…
Universal Credit is the government's flagship reform of the benefits system. Universal Credit was introduced to simplify the benefit system but has proved to be unpopular with many. In this article we consider the implications for defendants and insurers who are responsible for re-paying social…
Back to top
The Justice Secretary David Gauke has unveiled the Civil Liability Bill to Parliament. The bill includes reforms to clampdown on whiplash claims as well as changes to the way the personal injury discount rate is calculated for serious injuries.
In a statement from the Ministry of Justice, Justice…
We are pleased to announce that the Forbes Insurance Department has been shortlisted for the Insurance Post Claims Award in the strongly contested category of Insurance Law Firm of the Year for work in fraud and social care.
These Awards celebrate the achievements and progress made by the leading…
Gilpin v Blackburn with Darwen Borough Council
DJ Hinchcliffe - Preston CC
The claimant alleged that as she was crossing the road after alighting from a taxi, she tripped and stumbled in a pothole and fell onto her outstretched hand.
The residential cul de sac was subject to an annual…
Mabb v English  EWHC 3616 (QB)
The Court has ruled that it is not an abuse of process for a claimant to file a notice of discontinuance to avoid possibly having to pay the defendant's costs.
The claimant sought damages from the defendant for alleged clinical negligence. The…
It has been reported by the Motor Accidents Solicitors' Society that Ministry of Justice officials have confirmed that the government will implement the proposed reforms to the RTA system from April 2019, with personal injury reforms to be introduced at a later date.
It is understood that the…
Barton (Appellant) v Wright Hassall LLP (Respondent)  UKSC 12
The Supreme Court has confirmed that the rules of service apply to all litigants regardless of whether or not they are represented.
Mr Barton acting as a litigant in person brought a negligence action…
Corstorphine (An Infant) v Liverpool City Council (2018) EWCA Civ 270
The Court of Appeal has provided further guidance on the application of QOCS. The court was asked to consider whether QOCS should apply to defendants added to proceedings after 1 April 2013 where the existing claim was…
Back to top
The Claimant, aged 76 at the date of the accident, alleged that she sustained a personal injury after tripping over a base level barrier after collecting her grandchild from school. The school was partly under construction and base level barriers are generally used to segregate pedestrian walkways…
Wigan Council - DDJ Glassbrook - Wigan County Court
A Claimant had her highways claim dismissed at trial after giving unconvincing evidence.
The Claimant alleged that she was walking along a road one evening with her friend, when her right foot got stuck in a pothole. She pleaded that she…
Barnes v Tameside Metropolitan Borough Council
A Judge dismissed a claim for personal injury after finding that the Claimant had failed to prove her claim.
In April 2014, the Claimant alleged that she was walking home from the supermarket when she tripped on a defective grid and stubbed her…
Cook v Swansea City Council (2017) EWCA Civ 2142
The Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal from an Appellant Claimant after his claim for damages in negligence and/or breach of duty under s2(2) of the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 was dismissed.
The claim arose from an accident in…
Lord Keen of Elie QC has appeared before the House of Commons Justice committee to set out the government's agenda for personal injury reforms.
This one off session was intended to explain:
· the rationale and evidence supporting the Government's proposals for raising the…
London Organising Committee of the Olympic & Paralympic Games (In Liquidation) v Haydn Sinfield (2018) EWHC 51 (QB)
The Court have set out the correct approach to applications to have a personal injury claim dismissed for fundamental dishonesty pursuant to s.57 Criminal Justice and…
Various Claimants v WM Morrisons Supermarket PLC 2017 EWHC3113 (QB)
The High Court considered whether Morrisons supermarket ("the Defendant") was vicariously liable for an employee who intentionally disclosed personal details of staff on a file sharing website.
Back to top