Is it fair to dismiss Employees who are unable to provide documentary evidence of their right to work in the UK?

Wills, Probate, Tax & Trusts Article

12 January, 2018

The immediate answer in almost every organisation would be yes. S15 of the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006 makes it unlawful for an employer to employ an adult who is subject to immigration control. The penalties include civil and criminal sanctions even if the employer knew or had reasonable cause to believe that they did not have the appropriate immigration status. However, under s15 (3) there is a statutory excuse from the penalty if the employer can show that it undertook certain documentary checks.

Employers must:

  • Verify a person's right to work in the UK;
  • Conduct follow-up checks on employees who only have a limited amount of time;
  • Keep records of all checks carried out; and
  • Not employ anybody that they have reasonable cause to believe is an illegal worker

In the case of Baker v Abellio London (2017), Mr Baker was a Jamaican national who was a bus driver. Mr Baker was not subject to immigration control and had the right to live and work in the UK. His employer had requested further documentary evidence of this right and when this was not provided Mr Baker was suspended without pay and ultimately dismissed.

Initially the Employment Tribunal held that the dismissal was fair, however this decision has been subsequently overturned by the EAT. Whilst it is a potentially a fair reason to dismiss an employee if their continued employment would be illegal, you must be certain that it is actually illegal for the dismissal to be fair under the statutory restriction. If it later turns out that the employment was legal then the dismissal would not have been fair.

Nevertheless, this is not to say that you shouldn't dismiss if you have genuine concerns that the continued employment of that employee would be illegal. If this is the case you should ensure that a reasonable investigation has been carried out and that all other checks are exhausted before considering to dismiss. A dismissal in these circumstances may fall under Some Other Substantial Reason (SOSR) rather than the statutory restriction.

Our advice would be to ensure that careful checks are carried out prior to the appointment of all prospective employees and if for some reason suspicions arise later, you must ensure that reasonable investigations are carried out before dismissal is considered. Carrying out checks on all employees will also evade claims of discrimination by ensuring that not merely those people who appear to be of non-British descent are investigated.

If you are looking for any more information with regards to this or our services please view our Employment & HR section. You can also contact our Employment and HR department via email or phone on 03332 071135. Alternatively send any question through to Forbes Solicitors via our online Contact Form.


12 Jan 2018

Wills, Probate, Tax & Trusts


"One day, all of this will be yours": When the promise of inheriting a family business is broken

Ben Wilson, a solicitor who specialises in Wills, Trusts and Probate disputes considers how the promise of an…

Read the article

Excellent in every way.

Marjorie Whittam

More clients

Thank you to Patricia Prescott and her staff who dealt patiently and efficiently with my many queries.

Kathleen Garnett

More clients

All staff were helpful and approachable. Victoria Motley made what is a daunting experience bearable.

Maria Scully

More clients

The staff were very friendly and approachable.

Jack Greenhalgh

More clients

There was a quick and clear response to all questions raised.

Peter Butler

More clients

The service I received from Victoria Motley was excellent.

Janet Lloyd

More clients

Thanks to Victoria Motley. Very professional and efficient firm.

Leonard Mlotshwa

More clients

Everything was explained fully to us in terms we understood. Thank you Jennifer for making things so easy for us.

James Preston

More clients

Approachable, professional and friendly service. A strong combination, thank you.

Dorothy Beecroft

More clients

May I personally thank you for your professionalism and courtesy throughout our meetings.

Declan Bolger

More clients

The service provided was first class

Hilary Meller

More clients

Make an enquiry