Forbes at Trial: Claim Dismissed after Judge is Unable to Unpick the Circumstances of the Accident

Together we are Forbes

Article

15 August, 2019

Rees v Co-operative Group Ltd

The Claimant alleged that she had tripped in an uncovered drain situated in the car park of one of its stores. After investigating the claim, breach of duty was admitted but the Claimant was put to proof as to the manner and happening of the accident. It was the Claimant's case that she had been dropped off at the store by her mother and partner. She alleged that she fell in the car park a few minutes later and after phoning her partner, he returned to pick her back up.

The Claimant's partner and mother both provided witness evidence in support of the Claimant's case. The evidence from the three witnesses was found to be riddled with inaccuracies. Notably, the Claimant was not even able to identify the exact location of the defect.

Significantly, the contemporaneous GP records did not support the Claimant's version of events either. The Claimant alleged that she visited her GP three days after the accident. However, the corresponding entry in her GP records simply related to a telephone encounter for a repeat prescription. According to the medical records, the Claimant reported accident-related symptoms to her GP two weeks after the alleged accident - notably this attendance, took place shortly after the Claimant had first instructed solicitors.

The Judge found that the Claimant could not prove her case and dismissed the claim.

Forbes comment

The Claimant's evidence was so poor that the Judge was unable to unpick the circumstances of the fall. The discrepancies in the witness evidence was at times astonishing, with the witnesses being unable to agree on the most basic issues such as where the Claimant had been dropped off prior to the accident or where she had been picked up from. Regrettably, despite the inconsistencies the Judge did not take the view that this amounted to dishonesty and found that the Claimant and her witnesses were poor historians.

For more information contact Warren Smethurst in our Insurance department via email. Alternatively send any question through to Forbes Solicitors via our online Contact Form.

Contact Us

Get in touch to see how our experts could help you.

Call0800 689 3206

CallRequest a call back

EmailSend us an email

Contacting Us

Monday to Friday:
09:00 to 17:00

Saturday and Sunday:
Closed