22 September, 2020
The High Court has last week handed down judgment in the case of The Financial Conduct Authority and Others  EWHC 2448 (Comm).
This was a test case brought by the Financial Conduct Authority against several insurance companies to clarify the scope and meaning of Business Interruption (BI) insurance policies due to Government restrictions imposed as a consequence of the Covid-19 pandemic.
The Government lockdown restrictions imposed on the 23 March 2020 meant that all businesses selling non-essential goods or providing non-essential services were required to close. Many of these businesses made claims under their insurance policies for business interruption.
Given the growing number of claims being made under BI insurance policies, the FCA commenced the litigation in order to resolve the uncertainty surrounding BI insurance cover and Covid-19 and to ensure the fair treatment of policyholders by insurance companies and brokers.
The case sought clarity in relation to a number of common extensions to BI cover, namely:
The two main issues disputed by the Defendant insurers were as follows:
The Defendant insurance companies argued that BI cover would not be available as losses would have been sustained in any event, that some premises were not required to be closed due to the pandemic, and that global or national pandemics would not generally be covered under such policies.
Following the submission of the defences, the FCA invited policyholders, insurance intermediaries and other stakeholders the opportunity to provide comments on the Defences. These were then taken into account when the FCA were preparing their reply to defence and the trial took place over 8 days, commencing on 20 July 2020 and concluding on 30 July 2020. During the trial, the High Court considered a wide range of issues in relation to policy interpretation and causation and handed down judgment on 15 September 2020.
The Judgment can be found here: https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/corporate/bi-insurance-test-case-judgment.pdf
The High Court handed down judgment last week establishing important guidance on the proper construction of business interruption insurance policies. The judgment was in favour of the FCA on the majority of key issues and provides a silver lining to some policyholders, in deciding that most of the infectious disease clauses would provide cover to policyholders as a consequence of COVID-19.
Further, certain prevention of access clauses may provide cover depending on the wording contained therein and how the business was affected by the Government's response to the pandemic, including whether the business was required to close or not.
The test case also clarified that the COVID-19 pandemic and the Government's response to it were the single cause of loss to policyholders, which would be the key requirement for claims to be paid if these policies did indeed provide cover.
The Judgment brings welcome news to policyholders, allowing them to rely on the wordings contained within infectious diseases and hybrid policies in order to bring claims for business interruption.
This case does not provide clarity for all possible Covid-related insurance disputes and nor does it determine how much would be payable under a BI policy, but it does resolve the contractual uncertainty and issues in relation to causation for insurers and policyholders alike.
Some insurers have indicated that they will review the decisions in relation to BI cover to ensure that they are in line with court judgments and as such, the FCA expect that policyholders with affected claims will hear from their insurers within days of the Judgment.
It may be that the decision is subject to Appeal and therefore this may not quite be the end of the matter, but for now businesses will welcome the Court's decision. It is estimated that 700 different insurance policies administered by 60 insurance companies and over 300,000 policyholders could be affected by the test case.
For more information contact Stephen McArdle in our Business Dispute Resolution department via email or phone on 0333 207 1142. Alternatively send any question through to Forbes Solicitors via our online Contact Form.
Learn more about our Business Dispute Resolution department here